Tag: Taxable Income

The 50/50 Minimum Strategy:  Maintain 50% of your 401(k) and IRA money in Roth accounts

Why pay taxes today when you can postpone them until years later? The obvious answer is to delay paying taxes as long as possible.  But sometimes the obvious answer is not the best answer.  Let’s consider several assumptions that support the 50/50 Minimum Strategy.

First, if one invests the money that would have gone to taxes, it should compound over time and the total investments, less the eventual taxes to be paid, would potentially be greater than the amount of the Roth conversion, plus earnings.  The problem with this is most people will not diligently invest the money that would have gone to pay the tax.  It is more easily spent in the normal household budget.  And even if it were invested, the potential to keep it invested over a long period of time is dependent on many variables. 

Second is the assumption that a person’s income will be lower in retirement. This is true for many taxpayers.  However, many of our clients remain in a high tax bracket after retirement.  This is especially true if one has large IRA balances that require minimum distributions combined with large investment accounts that create capital gains. 

Third is the assumption that tax rates will remain relatively stable over time.  This is the most dangerous assumption.  Congress has the power to change the tax rates at any time and with the skyrocketing budget and related government debt, it appears likely that tax rates will be higher in the future. So, even if one’s income is lower, the tax rate could be higher. 

How high could tax rates go?  The following chart provides a history of the highest marginal tax rate for 1944 through 2022 for married couples filing jointly:

Years                                                 Highest Marginal Rate#                 Taxable Income Over#

1944 through 1951                           91%                                                 $200,000 (1950)

1952 through 1953                           92%                                                  $300,000 (1953)

1954 through 1963                           91%                                                   $300,000 (1958)

1964                                                  77%                                                   $200,000 (1964)

1965 through 1981                           70%                                                   $180,000 (1974)

1982 through 1986                           50%                                                   $108,300 (1984)

1987                                                  38.5%                                                $80,000 (1987)

1988 through 1990                          28%        (Bubble Rate 33%)           $78,400 (1988)

1991 through 1992                           31%                                                    $70,450 (1991)

1993 through 2000                          39.6%                                                  $288,350 (2000)

2001                                                  39.1%                                                  $297,350 (2001)

2002                                                 38.6%$                                                 $307,050(2002)                           

2003 through 2012                           35%                                                     $388,350 (2012)

2013 through 2017                           39.6%                                                  $444,550 (2017)

2018 through 2022                           37.0%                                                  $647,850 (2022)

#  Rate for Married Couples Filing Jointly

 Information provided by The Tax Foundation, Washington, DC. 20005

The strategy that we have continued to recommend to most of our clients is to approach retirement with a minimum of 50% of their IRA and 401(k) assets held in Roth accounts.  With this approach, an investor takes a balanced approach to the payment of taxes.  Pay taxes at the rates in effect now on the Roth contributions and conversion amounts while delaying the taxes on the non-Roth portion of their deferrals or contributions.  If we err on one side or the other, we prefer to convert more of the retirement assets and pay the taxes at today’s rates as opposed to leaving these assets subject to whatever future rate Congress enacts. 

If a client is charitably minded, we do not recommend converting ALL your IRA assets.  The preferred use of a portion of your IRA assets is to process Qualified Charitable Distributions (QCD) with the pre-tax IRA assets.  After age 70.5, taxpayers may donate money directly from their IRA to qualified charities utilizing the QCD provisions.  The annual limit on QCD donations is currently $100,000. 

ACTION:  Consider adopting the strategy of working towards a minimum Roth balance of 50% of your total retirement assets by your retirement date.  Work with your financial advisor to determine if you should convert a higher percentage. 

To discuss this article further or to learn more about CapSouth Wealth Management, visit our website at www.capsouthwm.com or call 800.929.1001 to schedule an appointment to speak with an advisor.

By: Donald P. Bolden, CFP®, CLU & Lewis Robinson, CPA

Investment advisory services are offered through CapSouth Partners, Inc, dba CapSouth Wealth Management, an independent registered Investment Advisory firm. Information provided by sources deemed to be reliable. CapSouth does not guarantee the accuracy or completeness of the information. CapSouth does not offer tax, accounting, or legal advice. Consult your tax or legal advisors for all issues that may have tax or legal consequences. This information has been prepared solely for informational purposes, is general in nature and is not intended as specific advice. Any performance data quoted represents past performance; past performance is no guarantee of future results.